Over-justification Effect

Offering extrinsic rewards for tasks that are intrinsically motivating can reduce the natural enjoyment or engagement with the task.
diversity_1
Social and Emotional Influence
sentiment_very_satisfied

Strengthens engagement by providing tangible rewards.

sentiment_sad

May reduce intrinsic motivation if over-rewarded.

Best paired with

Progressive Disclosure
Gradual exposure reduces reliance on external rewards.
Choice Architecture
Users are presented with options that prioritise engagement over rewards.
View more pairings
stadia_controller
Gamification
notifications
Notifications & Alerts
arrow_upward_alt
Behaviour Change
arrow_upward_alt
Retention
arrow_upward_alt
Trust & Confidence
arrow_downward_alt
Cognitive Load

Unlock actionable insights to take your product experience to the next level

Sign up now
checklist
Optimisations to get you started
Actionable suggestions for how to best use ingredients to improve your product experience.
sentiment_sad
Avoid negative impact
Actionable suggestions for how to best use ingredients to improve your product experience.
menu_book
Build your own resource
Add your go-to ingredients and cocktails to your menu for faster access later on.

The Study

Over-justification Effect explores how individuals' decisions and perceptions are influenced by underlying psychological mechanisms. Research on this bias has revealed its role in everyday behaviours and decision-making processes. Studies often involve experiments where participants' reactions are observed to determine the bias's impact. This understanding helps designers and marketers craft more effective, user-centric experiences.

The result

The results indicate that over-justification effect significantly influences decision-making by altering perception, recall, or emotional response. These findings provide valuable insights into cognitive behaviour, informing design strategies.

Actionable tips

1.

Balance intrinsic and extrinsic motivators.

2.

Use rewards sparingly to maintain engagement.

3.

Test reward frequency for sustained interest.

Ingredient pairings

sentiment_very_satisfied

Best pairings

add_circle

Progressive Disclosure

Encourages intrinsic motivation while preventing over-rewarding.
add_circle

Choice Architecture

Reduces reward dependency while preserving motivation.
add_circle

Feedback Loop

Supports sustainable motivation while avoiding dependency.
add_circle

Nudge

Encourages autonomy while guiding user behaviour.
sentiment_extremely_dissatisfied

Worst pairings

add_circle

Scarcity Principle

Exploits artificial limitation to drive engagement.
add_circle

Fear of Missing Out (FOMO)

Creates forced participation by overemphasising rewards.
add_circle

Default Bias

Discourages thoughtful choice in favour of extrinsic gain.
add_circle

Authority Bias

Reinforces external control over user autonomy.

Cocktails with this ingredient

There are no cocktails that currently contain this ingredient