Backfire Effect

Presenting evidence that contradicts a belief can cause individuals to cling more strongly to their original views instead of re-evaluating them.
touch_app
Usability and Interaction
sentiment_very_satisfied

Focuses user attention on critical elements.

sentiment_sad

May distract users from other important aspects.

Best paired with

Progressive Disclosure
Gradual exposure to information reduces defensive reactions.
Nudge
Gently encourages openness to opposing views over time.
View more pairings
notifications
Notifications & Alerts
view_carousel
Content Browsing
arrow_downward_alt
Errors
arrow_upward_alt
Retention
arrow_upward_alt
Behaviour Change
arrow_downward_alt
Cognitive Load
arrow_upward_alt
Trust & Confidence

Unlock actionable insights to take your product experience to the next level

Sign up now
checklist
Optimisations to get you started
Actionable suggestions for how to best use ingredients to improve your product experience.
sentiment_sad
Avoid negative impact
Actionable suggestions for how to best use ingredients to improve your product experience.
menu_book
Build your own resource
Add your go-to ingredients and cocktails to your menu for faster access later on.

The Study

The Backfire Effect refers to the strengthening of beliefs when confronted with contradictory evidence. Nyhan and Reifler (2010) conducted research to assess how fact corrections influence political misconceptions. Participants received accurate information that challenged their existing beliefs; the study found that some participants became more entrenched in their original views when faced with contradictory facts.

The result

The results indicated that correcting misinformation can backfire if it challenges deeply held beliefs. This insight suggests careful framing of factual corrections to reduce defensive reactions.

Actionable tips

1.

Correct misconceptions gently to reduce resistance.

2.

Use factual, neutral language for sensitive topics.

3.

Experiment with formats to deliver corrective info.

Ingredient pairings

sentiment_very_satisfied

Best pairings

add_circle

Progressive Disclosure

Encourages open-mindedness while minimising resistance.
add_circle

Nudge

Promotes adaptability without forcing perspective shifts.
add_circle

Feedback Loop

Supports learning while mitigating reactive rejection.
add_circle

Choice Architecture

Encourages engagement without triggering defensive bias.
sentiment_extremely_dissatisfied

Worst pairings

add_circle

Fear of Missing Out (FOMO)

Exploits defensiveness, worsening resistance to change.
add_circle

Scarcity Principle

Encourages hoarding of ideas rather than flexible thinking.
add_circle

Authority Bias

Encourages deference to power rather than logical evaluation.
add_circle

Confirmation Bias

Reduces exposure to new perspectives and critical thinking.

Cocktails with this ingredient

There are no cocktails that currently contain this ingredient